About Pets Pets Pets

Our Mission at Pets Pets Pets is simple: to increase the longevity of your loved one through holistic and proven nutrition. We listen to the needs of the community to provide a top-tier assortment of pet & animal supplies along with a best-in-class customer service. But we don't just sell pet food, we want to change the way people think about pet nutrition as a whole and offer an understanding of how different foods are sourced, manufactured, and processed in the body. Our philosophy boils down to one basic principle - Real Food equals Real Health. By choosing Pets Pets Pets, you can feel good about the food choices you make for your animal.

Pets Pets Pets has been operating since 1977, with John Whyte purchasing the store in November of 2022. Hailing from New Orleans, Louisiana, John first made his way into New Jersey following a technology start-up to work as a mechanical engineer. Either by luck or chance, John found himself in Califon as the new Owner-Operator of Pets Pets Pets and, driven by his passion for pet health, has hit the ground running in improving store performance and community engagement. John's loyal companions, Cami the Pittie and Mr. Bigs the Frenchie, can usually be found with him behind the counter where they add a healthy dose of fun and entertainment.